On 27 October 2021, the Education, Children and Young People Committee at the Scottish Parliament heard evidence from John Swinney, Deputy First Minister in the Scottish Government, on the continuing work to set up the Scottish in-care redress scheme and on particular pieces of secondary legislation in connection with this scheme. A link to the official report of this committee meeting is here.
Potential contributors and the “fair and meaningful” principles
As confirmed in our previous blog, here, as at 13 September 2021, no final agreements had been reached for any contributions to the scheme. Mr Swinney did not mention the position on this when giving evidence to the committee on 27 October. He did, though, explain that Scottish Government are “still going through some fairly sensitive negotiations about provider contributions” and that the final version of the “fair and meaningful principles” to be applied by Scottish Government in determining whether a contributing organisation should benefit from the waiver provisions of the scheme “will be published when we launch the scheme”, which remains anticipated by the end of 2021.
Draft secondary legislation on the form and content of the waiver was discussed, with the position remaining as summarised in our previous blog, here. If the committee wishes to produce a report on these regulations, it must do so by the end of this month.
Exceptions to eligibility
Draft secondary legislation on exceptions to eligibility for redress payments was also discussed. These provide that if a person was abused when resident in a relevant care setting for short-term respite or holiday care as arranged by a parent or guardian, any such abuse may not be used as the basis for a redress application. The committee has until 16 November 2021 to produce a report on these regulations if it wishes to do so.
Legal fees and other costs
The secondary legislation already in place on legal fees and other costs in connection with the redress scheme was considered. The position on this remains as confirmed in our previous blog, here, though the committee’s convener observed that there are “ongoing discussions” with the Law Society of Scotland on concern raised by some in the legal profession that the fixed expenses may not provide adequate remuneration where a solicitor appears before a redress panel in person. The committee has until 8 November 2021 to produce a report on these regulations if it wishes to do so.
Frank Hughes, Partner and Fiona McEwan, Associate
email@example.com and firstname.lastname@example.org